I mean yes, Sting and Darby are sadistic assholes lmao. Sting once sent a group of people that looked like him to get their ass beat by the NWO while he casually walked in to catch them by surprise.
I mean, I can understand your complaints to an extent, but the idea that Sting and Darby would stand on the ramp visibly agonizing over saving somebody they don’t even like just doesn’t fit their characters at all. At the end of the day they feel obligated to do what’s right- and Darby has personal reasons to hate Andrade- but they aren’t going to feel emotionally torn over saving Matt Hardy, not at this point. Save a conflicted moment like that for characters it would actually align with.
I do agree the whole thing felt a little off. I feel like it would have been better to have Jeff come out first and then have Sting and Darby run out with some urgency, looking after Jeff rather than Matt.