for me, my original caws Gary Masters & Killer Kadoogan are my two oldest, dating back to WWF Attitude back when CAW was first invented. Gary has always had a MMA-based moveset and Killer has always looked like a cross between Minoru and a unmaked Vader and has always had a Japan based vader moveset. My recent ones when I was able to start doing their movesets were Erik Based off of Retro Lesnar moveset and look wise, my karl gotch, billy robinson, bruiser brody, dan severn, harley race, thesz, (and i know im forgetting a few others) inspired moveset wise caws as these caws can literally wrestle circles around most other of my CAWS and also ingame superstars even though they might have higher attributes. Also my WCW/ECW Based Rey looking CAW El Grapadura, he always makes the cut as I have loved Rey and really have fond memories of the WCW cruiserweight division with the real Y2 (as I never liked it when Jericho changed everything in WWF, but I can unerstand why..)
So here is some of mine, who are yours ? Who will be appearing for sure in 2k19 in your game ?